The Dungeon Dive - Revisiting the Games on the Top 10 Lists (A Project for 2025 that won't destory the planet)

Starting soon, I will be launching a series in which I am revisiting all the games on my two top 10 lists (Dungeon Crawls, and Adventure Games).

There are two main reasons I want to do this.

  1. I’m pretty burned out on learning and playing new games
  2. I just want to play games that I know I’ll love playing

The Games up for consideration will be:

Top 10 Adventure Games

  • Lands of Galzyr
  • Runebound 2nd Edition
  • Dungeon Degenerates
  • Arkham Horror 2e (probably won’t do this one because of the ongoing series)
  • Albion’s Legacy
  • Hexplore It: Valley of the Dead King
  • Sleeping Gods
  • A Touch of Evil
  • Fallen Land 2e
  • Pauper’s Ladder

Top 10 Dungeon Crawls

  • Dungeon Crusade
  • Rogue Dungeon
  • Machina Arcana
  • Iron Helm
  • Warhammer Quest
  • Mansions of Madness 2e
  • DungeonQuest
  • WHQ: Silver Tower
  • Quest for the Lost Pixel
  • Secrets of the Lost Tomb

I’d like to use this thread for us all to discuss these 20 games. Feel free to discuss anything related to them.

The first game up will be Quest for the Lost Pixel. I’m not going to do them in any order, and I will most likely skip making a special video for Arkham Horror because we’re still working on that series.

11 Likes

I’m looking forward to this!

This was the shortest level one dungeon I’ve ever had!

3 Likes

Making my way through the Rainbow Rift, with a pretty good build going.

5 Likes

You went shopping right?

1 Like

I’m not sure if this is too far outside of the topic, but I recently got my hands on the Heroquest Roleplay Book that is basically a re-written Warhammer Quest Roleplay book for Heroquest. Curious what you think of it? If it is true enough to the Warhammer Quest Roleplay book to be worthwhile.

2 Likes

Absolutely understandable, so point number one.
I’m also a bit sad that these serines are not so well received by the “normal” YouTube viewer. Especially with the flood of videos that only scratch the surface, I think series like this are great for getting in-depth information about a game in order to make a good purchase decision, or simply to enjoy the video with approval.
I recently watched the Shadows of Brimstone series again while painting… fantastic.
As well as this top ten I think is super good.
It’s a great update on your favorites. Has anything changed, has the feel for a game stayed the same, or is there new input…
I’m looking forward to it…

3 Likes

I’ve had a quick glance at that HQRPG book, but I think it looks pretty cool.

I think it would be neat to make videos about the stories that occur when playing your games. I’ve kind of done this w/ some of my own Dungeon Degenerates play throughs.

You don’t need to go into details about the mechanics of the games. Just tell the story! “The prisoners were freed under the condition to retrieve a head and deliver it. So and so decided to betray the offer, take the head and run. We encountered these monsters as we made our way up the pass to the highlands, only to have X character be defeated. The necromancers corruption was spreading fast down in the swamps, so these two degenerates broke off to the group to calm the savage lands. After completing the next mission the gang decided it was time to make a base. X Y Z happened.”

Something like that! I take pictures of my game states and kind of do little narrations like that for my friends in discord sometimes. I like good mechanics but I love great theme, and the sense of story that comes out of it. A couple videos just describing the stories that are generated while waxing quickly over the mechanics would be fun I think.

I have no idea if anyone else thinks this would be fun, but I do! lol

Tell me the story of your HexCrawl SoB posse! Dungeon Degenerates party, or something like that. I’d love to hear the story from that new space game you like so much, Wandering Galaxy.

You could play your favorite games. You don’t have to worry about filming it, actively narrating while you play. Just take some pictures, put them on the screen and describe the story to us. You get all of the fun parts of gaming, with none of the “youtube production” stress.

5 Likes

I love this idea and have been considering it. :slight_smile:

4 Likes

Your game designer interviews have always been a highlight. As you revisit these top Dungeon Crawls and Adventure Games, it’d be great to hear from the creators—insights into how these games came to be and any future plans they’re mulling over could add a fresh angle to the series.

6 Likes

Great idea. I love the battle reports on Peachy Tips, they are entirely narrative with no dice rolling.

3 Likes

Ohhhh I would love an interview with Sean Äaberg, the Dungeon Degens fella.

4 Likes

Next up for reevaluation is another rogue-like dungeon crawl, DungeonQuest.





6 Likes

Brother Gherinn escaped Dragonfire Castle with a vast amount of treasure!


6 Likes

Man, I love this game. Both the original and the fantasy flight remake. I played it a year or so ago with my wife and young son….he pulled the chasm/pit on his first turn and jumped, and fell to his death :rofl:. It was an amazing first game experience; he took it in his stride though.

3 Likes

Dying on your first time is a right of passage!

1 Like

I own, love and frequently play 5 games on these two lists, have 2 more of them already in shipment to me, and 1 more on my wishlist.

1 Like