Top 5 Games that Deserved More Attention

Daniel (@dungeondive) picks five games the hobby underserved, and for each one argues both halves of the case: why it was overlooked, and why it shouldn’t have been. A theme emerges almost immediately — most of these were sunk by how they looked rather than how they played, and nearly all of them are now dead.

Champions of Hara is bright and colourful enough to read as a light family game, which misdirects the audience that would actually love it: Tom Chick called it a better Mage Knight, and Daniel agrees. Space Cadets: Away Missions has the opposite problem — a grey, inert table presence hiding one of his favourite dice systems, where surplus successes become a currency you spend on interesting things. Hand of Fate: Ordeals was strangled by Kickstarter exclusives and a licence that will keep it out of print; he wants someone to lift the engine into a new setting, because it is still the best deck-building adventure game he knows.

Darkest Night second edition suffers from a one-action turn that sounds crippling and is in fact the point — guerrilla warfare in small increments, with some thirty-seven characters. And at number one, Myth: a catastrophic rulebook, a legendary Kickstarter failure, an edition upgrade maze, and beneath all of it a genuinely unique modular skirmish sandbox. “The best game I wouldn’t wish upon my worst enemy.”


Which underappreciated game would you most like to see rescued — reprinted, reimplemented, or simply rediscovered?