The Dungeon Dive's Top 50 Games of All Time* - part 1

Daniel (@dungeondive) opens the unscientific top-50 with a confession: he ran 200 dungeon-crawl and adventure games through the Pub Meeple comparison engine in a single sitting, took the top 50, and is rolling them out ten at a time. The cutoff at 50 is honest — anything below would just be more games he likes — and the rankings are framed as a snapshot, not a verdict.

Numbers 50 to 41: Runebound 3rd Edition (with Unbreakable Bonds — solid co-op threat management, the pog combat is at least unique), Dungeoneer: Tomb of the Lich Lord (a 2003 competitive crawl with a clever glory/peril economy), Aftermath (Watership Down meets dungeon crawl — charming world, terrible rulebook), Fallout (with the Atomic Bonds expansion to fix the drab base game), Shadows of Malice (abstract, demands player imagination), LotR: Journeys in Middle-earth (great app, too many tiles), Advanced HeroQuest (best dungeon-toolbox rules, but the box is famously paltry — better treated as a HeroQuest expansion), Assault on Doomrock (terrific combat, way too long), Tomb (an abundance of art and ambition that the design never quite earns — Daniel keeps it on potential alone), and Warhammer Quest: Blackstone Fortress (GW’s most-supported specialty box, lacklustre character progression).


Tomb is the controversial entry — included for what it could be rather than what it is. Is there a game in your collection you keep around for its potential, hoping someone (you, the designer, the fan community) eventually cracks it?