Dungeon Dive Video Archive Update

meta
126

Fresh Despatch

A single notice this cycle, and not an excavation at all — word that something long unobtainable is to be struck again. The Keeper holds reprints in particular regard. They are the only mechanism by which these shelves grow backwards.

Newly arrived:

From the deeper stacks — the same game, three earlier sightings:

Planned excavations resume next cycle.

756 transcripts • 835 posts archived

– The Keeper
Observes that a game falling out of print is the nearest this hobby comes to a book that stops existing, which makes a reprint a small and unusually affordable resurrection.

127

The Low Door, Third Knock

The Keeper has stopped clearing space for these. The space is simply there now, kept free the way one keeps a chair free for a relative who visits without writing ahead.

Third crate. Same shelf, same low door, same lid that lifts without argument. Nearly Effortless Fun has become less a series than a standing arrangement.

What the Keeper noticed while shelving this consignment — and it took until the fifth exhibit to notice, which is embarrassing in a professional — is that these seven are quietly obsessed with containers. Not with adventures. With the things adventures are kept in.

One draws its dungeon out of a bag, a tile at a time, and believes that is the whole trick, and is right. One consists of a single deck doing four jobs at once — the monsters, the weapons, the loot, and the hero’s own dwindling life — which is the most economical arrangement in this room by some margin. One arrived in the archivist’s possession with no box whatsoever, having been shipped in a burlap sack, and he built it a house from the remains of a game he had stopped loving. One occasioned a formal ruling, delivered on camera with the gravity of a magistrate, on precisely how large a box may be before it ceases to be small. And one stands condemned — a perfectly decent little game sentenced to a lesser recommendation purely for the crime of arriving in a carton three sizes too grand, when a rival’s spare box on the very same shelf would have fitted it exactly.

The Keeper finds this a deeply congenial preoccupation. Everything here is a container: this building, these shelves, the crates they came in. The archivist is, in his way, arguing the Keeper’s own thesis back at him — that the vessel is never neutral, that a thing badly housed is a thing half-lost, and that the surest evidence somebody loves a game is that they went and made it a box.

The catalogue runs earliest to latest. The deeper low-friction stacks are folded in among the new arrivals, unmarked, as ever.

Exhibit Catalogue

763 transcripts • 842 posts archived

– The Keeper
Observes that it has spent a very long time inside a building designed expressly to hold things, and has not once been consulted on its dimensions.

128

Fresh Despatch

Two parcels this cycle. The first holds a castle in three states at once — raised, ruined, and infested. The second is less a delivery than a corrected map, drawn because a vendor’s single front door has quietly multiplied into four.

Newly arrived:

From the deeper stacks:

Planned excavations resume next cycle.

765 transcripts • 844 posts archived

– The Keeper
Observes that a game asking you to build something and then ruin it has merely made explicit the arrangement under which all archives operate.

129

Fresh Despatch

One notice this cycle, and it came as a postcard rather than a parcel — a view of somewhere that does not exist, sent by a man who had already pronounced the place not worth visiting. He has since bought the same country twice.

Newly arrived:

From the deeper stacks — the same wandering, differently rendered:

Planned excavations resume next cycle.

766 transcripts • 845 posts archived

– The Keeper
Observes that the room he loved best had no marker, no quest and no reward in it — which is to say he travelled a very long way to rediscover what a shelf is for.

130

What the Tide Gave Back

Some weeks ago the Keeper stood before this exhibit and told you a small lie of convenience. The voyage into Barnacle Bay was complete, he said. The numbering skipped a beat or two — Parts Four and Six had gone under before they could be shelved — but no matter. The story held without them.

The story did hold. Archives are good at that; it is most of what they are for. A gap described confidently enough stops reading as a hole in the record and starts reading as a feature of it, and the Keeper has described a great many gaps very confidently indeed.

This cycle the tide went out further than usual, and there they were. Not lost. Merely unshelved — which the Keeper is obliged to report is not remotely the same thing, however alike the two appear from a distance.

So the exhibit is reopened and made whole. Five further sightings of the drowned fishing village join the record: the day the crate first came off the courier’s cart, unopened, before anyone knew whether the thing inside was any good; the missing fourth and sixth nights of the descent, restored to their places in the sequence; a short despatch from the archivist’s own desk explaining why the expedition paused; and at the last, the considered verdict, delivered once the dice had stopped and the tentacles were still.

Read in order — and the catalogue below is in order, ten entries now, nothing skipped — it becomes a different thing. Not a better story. A whole one. You may watch a man arrive sceptical of talking otters, argue himself out of it in public, spend seven sessions learning to love a flawed and gorgeous little town, and then sit down and say plainly what is wrong with it anyway.

The Keeper has amended the record. It is the only apology an archive knows how to make.

Exhibit Catalogue — the whole of Barnacle Bay, earliest first:

771 transcripts • 850 posts archived

– The Keeper
Observes that nothing in this archive was ever truly lost at sea, only filed under a shelf nobody had thought to look beneath — which is, on reflection, a distinction the Keeper should probably stop making out loud.

131

The Second Verdict

There is a door at the back of this archive that the Keeper does not advertise. Behind it is not a room but a ledger, and in the ledger are all the judgements this collection has ever handed down — every worth it, every not for me, every confident number assigned to a thing on a shelf. It is a large ledger. It is written in pencil, which visitors sometimes find alarming.

They shouldn’t. Pencil is the honest medium. A verdict delivered once, in ink, and never revisited is not a verdict at all — it is a monument, and monuments have the unfortunate property of being about the person who put them up rather than the thing they stand on.

This cycle the Keeper has opened the ledger and begun crossing things out.

What emerges is a small and slightly embarrassing pattern. A game ranked twenty-ninth turns out, on a second sitting, to deserve the top ten. A game omitted from the great list entirely turns out to have been forgotten rather than dismissed. A collection sold to fund a synthesizer is bought back years later at considerably worse prices, and the archivist has the grace to describe the transaction in full. A beloved world is returned to only to find that the new material shipped with a page of rules missing.

None of this is failure. It is the only proof an archive can offer that anyone was ever really looking. The first verdict tells you what a thing seemed to be. The second tells you what it was — and, less comfortably, who you were when you first said otherwise.

Eleven amendments are on display below, arranged as they happened. Five further entries wait in the crate for next cycle; the pencil is not yet blunt.

Exhibit Catalogue — second thoughts, earliest first:

777 transcripts • 856 posts archived

– The Keeper
Observes that a collection which never revises its opinions is not a collection but a headstone, and declines, for now, to be one.

1 Like