A solo crawler where you might not make it out alive. How hard is too hard?

Hey all.

I’m making Six Faces of Darkness, a solo D6 dungeon crawler.

You wake up in a cave with no memory and try to get out before your light runs out, and along the way you slowly remember who you were. It’s coming in early 2027 as PDF and print, and the printed proof is on its way right now.

The thing I’m thinking about a lot is difficulty. Even if you play smart and do everything right, you make it out about 6 times in 10. The other 4 you die, and a lot of those deaths happen close to the exit. There’s no big boss at the end. What gets you is bad stuff stacking up. Your torch dies, your sword breaks, and suddenly you’re fighting blind.

I made it that way on purpose. I want every run to feel tense and to give the journal something real to write about. But I’m curious how that lands for you.

  • Would losing 4 games out of 10 make you want to go again, or put you off after the first death?
  • Do you like a solo game that is dark and unforgiving, or one where you usually win and the story is the point?
  • If you die close to the exit, does that feel unfair, or does it make the next run better?

For context, a run takes about an hour if you just play it straight, and longer if you journal. The idea, rules and writing are mine, translated into English with AI help (I’m not a native English speaker). The art is AI generated (I can’t draw to save my life).

The page is here if you want to have a look or follow along: https://luvengames.itch.io/six-faces-of-darkness

1 Like

Most of my gaming is done cooperatively, but we generally like a tougher game if it’s just a one night affair. Losing 6 out of 10 would still have us trying again if we liked the game. I think the most recent thing we played that was that tough would’ve been Fate: Defenders of Grimheim and we definitely lost that game at least 6 times before securing our first win. Each game took at most 2 hours, but I think it might’ve been even shorter than that… Not in the same style as what you’re making, but in a quick game that’s easy to restart it’s alright to be a bit more brutal in my opinion.

I definitely like the idea of what kills you being little things stacking up to overwhelm you before you can get to the end. I think that can be more interesting than just doing the boss fight thing.

2 Likes

thanks, thats really helpful. and yeah thats the idea, a quick game you can restart right away so losing doesnt feel like a wasted evening. small correction, its actually the other way around, you get out about 6 in 10 and die in 4, but sounds like even the tougher version would still work for you. the stacking stuff was the whole point for me, a boss fight felt like the wrong ending for a game about getting out. havent played defenders of grimheim, what kept you coming back after all those losses?

Yep, we’d be fine with even a 20-33% winrate on some games. Makes those wins feel meaningful. But we might put up with loss better than most.

Fate:DoG is a town defense sort of game. I’ve heard some people say at 4 players everyone just sits outside the town killing things as they approach. I can’t vouch for that, but at 2 players you need to be all over the map and selecting the right upgrades for your characters to get it done. Asymmetrical characters with multiple builds each creates a lot of strategical decision making. Also, the game is both tight and tough. You need to learn the characters to succeed on the harder difficulty. The randomness of enemy spawns can also make games feel pretty varied. All of that kept us coming back loss after loss. And also we could get a handful of plays in for a single night.

2 Likes

thats really interesting, random spawns and short sessions sound like exactly why it works. every loss plays out differently so you want to see what happens next time. thats kinda what im going for too, the cave changes every turn so no two runs feel the same, and since a game is fairly quick a loss doesnt sting that much. the builds part is cool too, in mine its less about choosing a build and more about what you happen to find and how you use it. thanks, this was really helpful!

2 Likes

I like that bit too, when a game forces you to make do with whatever random things you find.

1 Like

yeah same. in mine you mostly get one thing at a time, an old torch, a cracked sword, a flask with nothing in it, and you have to decide if its worth carrying. sometimes the best find is armor that falls apart a few turns later. it kinda makes you attached to junk. is there a game that does the scavenging thing really well for you? always looking for good examples

I’m trying to think of some… We played The Waste of Parts recently and it had some of that. But not quite desperate enough. Hellbringer often has your build being dependent on what drops, but it again doesn’t feel quite desperate enough to be what you’re talking about either.

Ker Nethalas in the early game, when starting out. I’ve got a shit memory, but my character had the drug addict flaw so I was always processing the first bit of potential food drops into drugs and scrounging harder to eat (or something like that). And I think I started with just a hammer and some greaves.

Sometimes Arkham Horror LCG has brief moments like that… Especially before you have a good grasp of how to build a deck. I recall a game where my wife ran out of ammo in her shotgun and finished the Dunwich Horror by punching it back into its rift. :laughing:

But now I feel we’re severely lacking in games that make me scrounge for trash just to get by. Feels like something more commonly done in video games maybe? Old ones… The opposite of a power fantasy.

EDIT: I haven’t played 12 Years yet. That might have some scrounging in it. And my GM ran an old school dungeon for us called The Lost City, and the early game definitely had us scrounging for anything useful. If you ate the contaminated food bad things happened…

1 Like

the opposite of a power fantasy, thats a great way to put it, its pretty much exactly the feeling im after. the contaminated food bit made me laugh, in mine eating something you found can backfire too and leave you weaker for a turn, so when youre low you really have to think about it. havent played Ker Nethalas, but it caught my eye, starting with just a hammer and greaves sounds like my kind of game. and punching the Dunwich Horror back into its rift is a legendary ending

2 Likes